Digital property valuations are landing about as close to the benchmark as full inspections, according to new Cotality research. The findings come as demand for valuations is set to rise.
Cotality’s Valuation Accuracy Benchmarking Report analysed about 1.17 million lending records over a rolling two-year period. It compared the company’s own digital products – the IntelliVal automated valuation model (AVM), Cotality Desktop and SMARTval – with full inspection valuations of the same properties, adjusting for market movement between assessment dates.
More than 103,000 loans were refinanced with another lender in the June quarter of 2026, according to Australian Bureau of Statistics data cited in the report. Capital gains tax changes announced in the May 2026 Budget could also mean about 2.4 million investment properties may require a valuation as at 1 July 2027, subject to confirmation of the scope.
Not every investor will necessarily need one, however. Under the Budget design, an investment property’s value at 1 July 2027 becomes its cost base for future capital gains, and investors can establish it through an independent valuation or an ATO apportionment formula. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Australia has encouraged investors and their tax advisers to consider independent professional valuations ahead of the change.
Cotality said digital assessments could help applications move without a site visit, leaving full inspections for properties that need them. The report argued that “a faster assessment need not mean a less reliable one”.
Within ±10% of the benchmark, 77% of IntelliVal AVM assessments fell within range, along with 76% of Cotality Desktop valuations and 80% of SMARTval assessments.
To set a realistic yardstick, Cotality also compared separate full inspections of the same property carried out by different valuation firms. Those came within ±10% of each other in 78% of cases. The report said this reference point recognises that “two valuers will not necessarily arrive at the same figure”.
SMARTval, which combines data validation with professional valuer judgement, scored highest at the ±5%, ±10% and ±15% ranges. The gap between the highest- and lowest-scoring methods was just three to five percentage points at each range. However, the report cautioned that SMARTval’s sample of about 48,800 assessments was the smallest, so “it cannot be concluded that SMARTval is inherently more accurate or would outperform the other methods on every lending application”.
Results were strongest for properties valued between $500,000 and $1 million, which make up 57% of the dataset. All four methods recorded at least 80% within ±10%, except Desktop at 79% in the $500,000 to $700,000 bracket.
Accuracy eased at the top end. In the $1.5 million to $2 million range, AVMs recorded 64% within ±10%, compared with 70% for Desktop, 73% for full inspections and 74% for SMARTval. AVM and Desktop results were assessed only up to $2 million.
Get the hottest and freshest property and mortgage news delivered right into your inbox. Subscribe now to our FREE daily newsletter.