Major bank CEOs throw brokers under the bus for growing fraud problem

But brokers aren't buying it

Major bank CEOs throw brokers under the bus for growing fraud problem

News

By Kellie Ell

Major bank chief executive officers are increasingly pointing the finger at mortgage brokers when it comes to the issue of mortgage fraud.

Earlier this month, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (ANZ) Chief Executive Officer Nuno Matos told a parliamentary hearing that most mortgage fraud identified in the bank's review came through the broker channel. 

“It’s fair to say that the majority of fraud was coming from broker channels, which means that we also have to do a better job in protecting good information in that channel,” Matos said, while appearing before the House of Representatives standing committee on economics in Canberra.

"We had very few cases; in a nutshell, the internal fraud component of the problem is basically non-existing, maybe two, I think we had two cases where we spotted some connection, so the vast majority were external agents,” he continued. 

But the CEO did acknowledge that in most cases it was "not possible to say" whether "the documentation was faked by the broker or by the customer or by someone else. It’s not possible to say.”

A few days later, Westpac Chief Executive Officer Anthony Miller made similar comments when he appeared before the same parliamentary committee in Canberra, suggesting that mortgage fraud had become more sophisticated with the growing involvement of brokers.

“The idea that someone misrepresents so that they can get a loan or a larger loan has been a challenge for the banks forever, and it is a bit more sophisticated now with the brokers,” he said. “The other risk that has emerged over the last few years is clearly with the broker having such a more significant role in the ecosystem, brokers facilitating or colluding with that kind of activity is something that we are cautious of."

The comments come amid increasing reports nationwide of mortgage fraud and scams. 

This past fall, reports surfaced, suggesting that mortgage fraud had already become a multi-billion-dollar threat to Australia's lending sector. The news put brokers and lenders on alert, and prompted many to take a closer look at how loan applications are verified. 

A common feature of these schemes is the manipulation of financial information, with borrowers allegedly altering or fabricating income documents to secure loans beyond their genuine borrowing capacity. The growing sophistication of artificial intelligence tools is adding another layer of complexity, giving fraudsters the ability to produce increasingly convincing documentation that can be more difficult for lenders to identify.

The industry has been quick to respond. 

In May of this year, Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) issued a warning over the growing cyber risks posed by artificial intelligence, and urged financial services licensees and company directors to take immediate precautions. ASIC later said fraud is one of its 2027 strategic priorities.  

Most recently, the Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia (MFAA) released its new Referrer Risk Management Guidance. The guide is meant to help brokers better identify and manage potential fraud risks associated with referrals across Australia's lending landscape.  

Not all brokers, however, agree with the suggestion that mortgage fraud is primarily coming through the third-party channel. 

"I'm sure if I was the CEO of a major bank, I'd be looking for someone else to blame as well," Daniel Green, founder, director and finance broker of Queensland-based brokerage Green Finance Group, told Australian Broker. 

Green argued that a large part of the problem stems from inexperienced brokers entering the industry without adequate support, training or oversight. 

"Inexperienced brokers either need to be working under a larger group, or some of these aggregators need to be held responsible for accrediting some of these inexperienced brokers as well," he said. "And if you don't have that experience [as a broker], you have to be mentored by somebody and you have to be part of a larger group. 

"And it's not just brokers; it's banks and brokers. It's coming from both sides," Green added. "I know Westpac went through this recently where there's been a number of fraud cases where clients go direct to bank."

Grant Arbuckle, managing director of Melbourne-based brokerage Loan Studio, said the idea that brokers are solely responsible for fraud is misguided. 

"It would be naive to think — that if we're throwing the blame at brokers — that there wouldn't be bankers as well out there doing exactly the same thing to get a deal done," he said. "The broker channel is generally the easy cop-out of the way to look at. It's probably an unfair comment to taint everyone with the same brush."

Arbuckle also pointed to broader economic pressures, arguing that the challenging lending environment — characterised by higher interest rates, rising living costs, inflationary pressures, falling property prices and geopolitical uncertainty — are also contributing to the problem. 

"The market is tougher for home lending. And unfortunately, during tough times, there will be people, not just in broking, but in all industries who may consider doing things they wouldn't normally do," he said. "So what happens, unfortunately, is for some people, they then exhaust options of whatever they can do. And that might mean there are people out there, across all industries, who will cut a corner to be able to get a deal done.

"We take the brush with brokers, but there are a lot of bankers out there — and again, I'm doing exactly what the CEOs are doing and putting it back to them — but there would be a lot of bankers doing that same thing," Arbuckle added. 

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!