Industry groups warn trust tax threatens housing supply

Five business bodies urge Senators to block discretionary trust changes as drafted

Industry groups warn trust tax threatens housing supply

News

By Mina Martin

Five major business and property groups have urged Senators not to pass the federal government’s discretionary trust tax changes in their current form. They warn the reforms will add to building costs and could stall housing projects.

In an open letter, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI), the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA), the Housing Industry Association (HIA), Master Builders Australia, and the Property Council of Australia said the legislation, due before the Senate in the final sitting weeks of the year, would fall hardest on small family businesses, including builders and developers.

The letter came two days after the Senate Economics Legislation Committee recommended the Bills pass, following their passage through the House on 29 October.

Housing supply in the firing line

The groups cited a recent survey in which 60% of small and medium residential and commercial developers said the policy would affect the timing or viability of their projects. Of those, 37% expected at least one project to be cancelled.

Because many family-owned building firms are structured as discretionary trusts, the letter argues that restructuring, compliance and administration costs would ultimately be passed on to homebuyers. It said “we need to let builders get on with the job, not add more hurdles and disincentives.”

‘None of these is a real choice’

The groups say around 350,000 small family businesses operate through discretionary trusts.

Under the legislation, they argue, these businesses would have to choose between three options: paying a 30% minimum tax from the first dollar of trust income, electing into a fixed-distribution regime where any variation in distributions, even a mistaken one, could see a full year’s income taxed at 47%, or restructuring into a company or fixed trust at a cost of tens of thousands of dollars per business.

The letter put it bluntly: “For small businesses and family builders, none of these is a real choice.”

Estimates of the compliance burden vary widely. CPA Australia told the Senate inquiry the trust measures could require $2.0 billion to $2.8 billion in professional advice before any restructuring, plus $221 million to $595 million a year in ongoing compliance, against Treasury’s estimate of $48 million.

The government’s case

The government says the 30% minimum tax will apply to discretionary trusts’ taxable income from 1 July 2028, with expanded rollover relief from 1 July 2027 for businesses that want to restructure into a company or fixed trust.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers has said more than 90% of small businesses would not be affected in any given year, and Treasury analysis found families using discretionary trusts paid an average tax rate around four percentage points lower than similar-income families without one.

The signatories said they backed tax integrity measures but wanted a more targeted approach. They added: “We support integrity in the tax system and are committed to working with the Government to address genuine concerns.”

Get the hottest and freshest property and mortgage news delivered right into your inbox. Subscribe now to our FREE daily newsletter.

 

 

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!